Pies & Tarts

50+ Easy Southern Pie Recipes

bourbon-pecan-pie-with-blondie-crust-featured

These Southern pies will make your mouth water, your heart race, and will send you straight to the kitchen to get to baking because they are just that good.


If your childhood wasn't made of different types of pies, then I don't know what to say. 

I am so sorry, friend. 

Sweet potato pies. Pumpkin pies. Peanut butter pies. 

All manner of Southern pies. 

Oh and let's not forget pecan pies that were made after you spent hours outside picking up pecans with your bare hands until they made those little roller wheel thingies. 

Hours of my childhood. Hours.

southern peanut butter pie

The sky is the limit now that we have the world wide web giving us so much inspiration, so without further ado...

Southern Pies You're Gonna Love

Let's get down to it, friend.

Let's watch how to make the first pie on our list: The Apple Slab Pie.

50+ Easy Southern Pie Recipes

These Southern pies will make your mouth water, your heart race, and will send you straight to the kitchen to get to baking because they are just that good.

  1. apple-slab-pie-feature.jpg

    Apple Slab Pie

    This apple slab pie with crumble topping is super yummy and perfect for fall desserts and parties. Comfort food at its finest!

    Get the recipe →
  2. key-lime-slab-pie.jpg

    Key Lime Slab Pie

    This key lime slab pie is yummy and great for gatherings when you need more than a 9″. It’s sweet and tasty and will fly off the table.

    Get the recipe →
  3. peach-crumble-slab-pie.jpg

    Peach Crumble Slab Pie

    Peach crumble slab pie is a great dessert for fresh peaches. It uses an oatmeal crumble topping that you can pair with ice cream for a yummy dish.

    Get the recipe →
  4. sweet-potato-slab-pie-feature.jpg

    Sweet Potato Slab Pie

    This sweet potato pie serves more than the typical round one and has a yummy store bought crust for some corner cutting.

    Get the recipe →
  5. No-Bake-Chocolate-Peanut-Butter-Pie-2a-wm.jpgfit3672c550ssl1.jpg

    No-Bake Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

    With the words chocolate, peanut butter AND no bake all together in the same name.... I literally don't know what to say. Making. For. Dinner.

    Get the recipe →
  6. No-Bake-Peanut-Butter-Pie-1263021.jpg

    Peanut Butter Pie with Chocolate Covered Pretzel Crust

    Pretzel crusts are a great way to make this cake gluten free. Just because you are GF doesn't mean you can't have pie. No siree.

    Get the recipe →
  7. Blackberry-Custard-Pie-11.jpg

    Blackberry Custard Pie

    We love fresh fruit and this pie combines blackberries with custard to perfection.

    Get the recipe →
  8. 20160616-IMG_6731.jpg

    Gooseberry Pie

    I'm not sure I've ever had gooseberries, but this is a great way to get introduced.

    Get the recipe →
  9. chess-pie-5461.jpg

    Old Fashioned Chess Pie

    My grandmother absolutely loved chess squares and chess pies. These are old fashioned and crowd favorites.

    Get the recipe →
  10. instant_pot_sweet_potato_pie.jpg

    Instant Pot Sweet Potato Pie

    Sweet potatoes AND the convenience and challenge of an Instant Pot? Sold.

    Get the recipe →
  11. pecan_pie_best_ever.jpg

    Pecan Pie Recipe (Without Corn Syrup)

    Puh-can... pee-cahn.... pee-can... doesn't matter what we call it, we can all agree it's great!

    Get the recipe →
  12. strawberry-rhubarb-pie.jpg

    Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

    An excellent combination of strawberry and rhubarb with a beautiful artisanal crust. Winner winner strawberry rhubarb pie for dinner.

    Get the recipe →
  13. Sour-Cream-Raisin-Pie-title-B.jpg

    Sour Cream Raisin Pie

    We love using sour cream here in the South in our baking, and this pie is no different. The lovely swirls on top seal the deal.

    Get the recipe →
  14. slice-of-blackberry-lemon-chess-pie.jpg

    Southern Blackberry Lemon Chess Pie Recipe

    Oh yeah, baby. Blackberry plus lemon plus the chess-ness we so do adore... this pie is beautiful and tasty.

    Get the recipe →
  15. peanut-butter-silk-pie.jpg

    Peanut Butter Silk Pie

    Silk pies are crowd favorites every time. This peanut butter silk pie will be a great addition to any family gathering or potluck.

    Get the recipe →
  16. derby-pie-sliced.jpg

    Better than Derby Pie

    Want a pie to watch the Kentucky Derby at your house? This Better Than Derby pie will be a surefire winner.

    Get the recipe →
  17. MG_8944.jpgfit6002c900ssl1.jpg

    Classic Sweet Potato Pie

    A classic sweet potato pie for sweet potato lovers (and those trying to break into it) alike.

    Get the recipe →
  18. easy-pecan-pie-toasty-kitchen-6.jpgfit8002c1200ssl1.jpg

    Easy Pecan Pie

    Another pecan pie that is beautiful and tasty. Great for church gatherings and potlucks and always a favorite among those who love old fashioned faves.

    Get the recipe →
  19. Chocolate-Pie-with-Graham-Cracker-Crust-Vert.jpg

    Chocolate Pie with Graham Cracker Crust

    Graham cracker crusts are so tasty and cozy. This chocolate pie will be a hit with kids and adults alike.

    Get the recipe →
  20. chocolate-pecan-pie-slice-2.jpg

    Chocolate Pecan Pie

    Pecans plus chocolate - winner. Who says you can't take an old favorite and give it a new twist?

    Get the recipe →
  21. Chocolate-Sweet-Potato-Pie-Vegan-Plant-Based-Planted365.com-1.jpgfit8332c1268ssl1.jpg

    Vegan Chocolate Sweet Potato Pie 

    If you aren't doing dairy or eggs, this vegan chocolate sweet potato pie is something you can have guilt free with all the flavor.

    Get the recipe →
  22. Make-an-Easy-Homemade-Pear-Baked-Dessert.jpg

    Homemade Spiced Pear Custard Pie

    This custard pie will be an excellent dessert when pears are in season. Homemade and delicious.

    Get the recipe →
  23. Buttermilk-Pie-Recipe-3-scaled-1.jpg

    The Best Buttermilk Pie Recipe

    Buttermilk just seems to take every recipe up a notch, right? Here's an awesome buttermilk pie recipe.

    Get the recipe →
  24. chocolate-chess-pie-recipe-13-of-13.jpg

    Chocolate Chess Pie

    Chess pie PLUS chocolate, who can say no to that?

    Get the recipe →
  25. lemon-pecan-pie-dairy-free-kitchen-gone-rogue_opt.jpg

    Dairy-Free Lemon Pecan Pie

    Are you dairy free but still want the joys of a pecan pie? Try this recipe and avoid the tummy aches.

    Get the recipe →
  26. Peach-Pie-Perfection-7.jpg

    Southern Peach Pie Perfection

    The crust on top of this pie is to die for. Bookmark this for peach season.

    Get the recipe →
  27. Gluten-Free-Crustless-Sweet-Potato-Pie-Vegan-Allergy-Free-Paleo-PM1.jpg

    Gluten-Free Crustless Sweet Potato Pie (Vegan, Allergy-Free, Paleo)

    If you have dietary restrictions but still want to indulge in the cozy yummy pies, this one is for you.

    Get the recipe →
  28. Apple-Crisp-Pie-Dutch-Apple-Pie-Vegan-Gluten-free-9.jpg

    Apple Crisp Pie

    A perfect way to use your big haul of fresh apples. You can't go wrong with this pie and a dollop of cream (or ice cream, who are we kidding?).

    Get the recipe →
  29. Blueberry-Pie-2.jpg

    Classic Blueberry Pie

    This blueberry pie with its lattice top is delightfully old fashioned and sweet.

    Get the recipe →
  30. Southern-Style-Blackberry-Custard-Pie-recipe-feature.jpg

    Southern Style Blackberry Custard Pie

    This is the best of both worlds. A cobbler with a pie..... and fresh blackberries to boot.

    Get the recipe →
  31. featured_buttermilkpie.jpg

    Coconut Buttermilk Pie

    My grandmother loved adding coconut to as many desserts as she could and she would have loved this fresh coconut buttermilk pie.

    Get the recipe →
  32. bourbon-pecan-pie-with-blondie-crust-featured.jpg

    Bourbon Pecan Pie with Blondie Crust

    Pecan + Bourbon... could this be a more buttoned up Southern dessert? Perfect to serve if you are aiming to impress or serving whiskey alongside your food.

    Get the recipe →
  33. Peanut-Butter-Pie-3.jpg

    No Bake Peanut Butter Pie - A Fave!

    Baking is awesome, but you know what else is awesome? Having a pie that is fast and quick and doesn't require baking. Perfect for budding bakers.

    Get the recipe →
  34. DSC5573.jpg

    Paleo No-Bake Maple Pumpkin Pie

    Are you on the paleo diet but still want a sweet pie to serve to your family? This will do it and the maple pie is an awesome touch.

    Get the recipe →
  35. wholesomeyum-keto-apple-pie-recipe-5.jpg

    Low Carb Keto Apple Pie Recipe

    Stay on diet and on plan and don't sacrifice any flavor with this amazing apple pie that doesn't include guilt as an ingredient.

    Get the recipe →
  36. wickedspatula-healthy-paleo-blueberry-pie-recipe-with-chocolate-chunks.jpg

    Paleo Blueberry Pie Recipe With Chocolate Chunks

    Another on diet beautiful pie that won't leave you feeling guilty long after you leave the table.

    Get the recipe →
  37. IMG_9918.jpg

    Chocolate Caramel Samoa Cookie Coconut Pie (Low Carb, THM S)

    This pie is low carb and Trim Healthy Mama approved. Used to be, to eat a pie you had to break all diets, not anymore!

    Get the recipe →
  38. IMG_6680.jpgfit29942c3739ssl1-scaled-1.jpg

    No Bake Lemon Cheesecake Pie

    A cheesecake and a pie put together. I don't know what to say but LET'S MAKE THIS RIGHT NOW.

    Get the recipe →
  39. pistachio-pie.png

    Easy Pistachio Pie Recipe

    Oh now, if you love a good pie and you love adding an unexpected twist, try this pistachio pie.

    Get the recipe →
  40. kentucky-derby-chocolate-pecan-pie-recipe-5.jpg

    Double Chocolate Kentucky Derby Pie

    This double choc pie will leave everyone feeling satisfied and ready for a good old fashioned nap.

    Get the recipe →
  41. Chocolate-Chess-Pie-Recipe.jpg

    How to Make a Chocolate Chess Pie (Chocolate Fudge in A Pie Crust)

    Chocolate fudge in a pie crust. Let's just start calling pies that from now on, shall we?

    Get the recipe →
  42. low-carb-pecan-pie-slice.jpg

    Low Carb Pecan Pie Recipe

    Another low carb keto friendly pecan pie you can eat without the guilt.

    Get the recipe →
  43. Buttermilk-Pie-fb_5046.jpg

    Buttermilk Pie

    Buttermilk is a "secret ingredient" used in so much of Southern baking and this pie is no different. Yum yum.

    Get the recipe →
  44. Pecan-Crunch-Sweet-Potato-Pie-4.jpg

    Pecan Crunch Sweet Potato Pie

    Ohhhhhhh look at that orange sweet potato pie topped with crunchy pecans... say it's in my refrigerator right now.

    Get the recipe →
  45. no-bake-peanut-butter-pie-featured-image.jpg

    No Bake Peanut Butter Pie

    If this glaze doesn't stop your scroll, I don't know what will.

    Get the recipe →
  46. anita-austvika-1128082-unsplash.jpg

    Grandma's Canned Apple Pie Filling

    Love this. Sometimes you want to peel apples and make apple pie fully from scratch. Sometimes you don't. Either way, you don't have to sacrifice the flavor!

    Get the recipe →
  47. deep-dish-peach-pie-FB.jpg

    DEEP DISH Peach Pie

    Here's a deep dish pie your guests and family will love.

    Get the recipe →
  48. Simple-Cinnamon-Apple-Rhubarb-Pie-Recipe-3555-2.jpg

    Cinnamon Apple Rhubarb Pie Recipe

    She's said rhubarb, she needs say no more.

    Get the recipe →
  49. Peanut-Butter-Apple-Crumb-Pie-13-705x1024-1.jpg

    Peanut Butter Apple Crumb Pie

    This is like the best of both worlds. A mix of peanut butter, apple pie, and CRUMB ON TOP!

    Get the recipe →
  50. oatmeal-pie-5-e1560227771929.jpg

    Oatmeal Pie {Mock Pecan Pie}

    If you aren't quite able to go full pecan (or don't have any on hand) try this yummy oatmeal pie. I mean.... between you and me.. you could eat this for breakfast.

    Get the recipe →
  51. strawberry-pie-with-frozen-strawberries.jpg

    Strawberry Pie With Frozen Strawberries

    Ohhhh you don't just need fresh fruit to make a good pie, try this strawberry pie made out of frozen strawberries. You can make it year round.

    Get the recipe →
  52. Mojito-Key-Lime-Pie-Title-Still-Food-Recipes_small-800x450-1.png

    Mojito Key Lime Pie Recipe

    A list of Southern pies would never be complete without key lime. Add mojito and you've got the makings of a good time.

    Get the recipe →
  53. How-to-Make-Mini-Cherry-Hand-Pies-Pop-Shop-America-534x800-1.png

    Mini Cherry Hand Pies Recipe

    Want to make bite sized pies everyone can enjoy individually? Try these cherry pies.

    Get the recipe →
  54. butternut-squash-pie.jpg

    Butternut Squash Pie Recipe

    You don't need to wait for Thanksgiving to make this delicious butternut squash pie!

    Get the recipe →
  55. Peanut-Butter-Pie.jpg

    Peanut Butter Pie

    Nothing like a good old fashioned mousse filled peanut butter pie.

    Get the recipe →
  56. Clean-Eating-Pecan-Pie11.jpg

    Clean Eating Pecan Pie

    Pecan pies are a Southern dessert staple.

    Get the recipe →
  57. Sweet-Potato-Pie-IG-e1570503113385.png

    Creamy & Flavorful Sweet Potato Pie

    Southern pie lists would never be complete without a sweet potato pie. Great for Thanksgiving or really, any time those sweet potatoes are in season.

    Get the recipe →

I hope you loved this collection of awesome Southern pies!

From our kitchen

50+ Delicious Southern Pies

3.5 from 2 votes

These Southern pies will make your mouth water, your heart race, and will send you straight to the kitchen to get to baking because they are just that good.

apple pecan pumpkin pies
Course
Dessert
Cuisine
American, Southern

Ingredients

0 of 57 ingredients checked

Instructions

  1. Select a pie from the list above.

  2. Follow the link to the recipe.

  3. Prepare and enjoy!